39 Responses

  1. Mizzou at |

    Joe Carter had a walk-off to win the World Series. No doubt that is #1.

    Reply
  2. Mizzou at |

    and where is Pujols? He set Brad Lidge's career back 5 years with one HR.

    Reply
    1. Unanimous at |

      how did he send lidge's career back?

      Reply
  3. Bob Canter at |

    Just two comments; this is actually a very good list with some excellent selections, but:

    1. I KNOW it's been overdone, but HOW COULD YOU NOT INCLUDE Bobby Tompson's home run in Game 3 of the 1951 Playoffs against the Brooklyn Dodgers? Most baseball historians still rate that one at #1 all-time!

    2. As an old Pittsburgh Pirates fan, thank you, thank you, THANK YOU for including Bill Mazeroski's magnificent, spectacular home-run in the 1960 World Series, which for some reason remains forgotten by many baseball fans. One minor technical correction: Maz's home run did not, as you state, end up in "…the left field bleachers." There were bleachers at old Forbes Field, but they were right down the left field line, completely in foul territory.

    Maz's historic home run went over the left field WALL, at the 406 mark, and into the street beyond. I never heard who actually recovered that ball.

    Reply
  4. Orleans Cardinals at |

    Second the vote for Pujols absolutely monstrous home run against Houston solely on the fact that Lidge has to essentially rehabilitate his career from that point on

    Reply
  5. Topher at |

    This is an awesome list. Even though the Sox didn't win I'd still rank Carlton Fisk higher. ;)

    Reply
  6. greg at |

    I guess this is the top 10 in recent history? Chris Burke but no Bobby Thompson? Hilarious

    Reply
  7. C.B. at |

    Actually, Bobby Thompson's home run was a great one, but it technically wasn't a playoff home run. The Giants-Dodgers match-up was not officially considered a playoff series, as the World Series was the only official playoff series until the formation of the LCS in 1969.

    Reply
  8. greg at |

    You must be a big Chris Burke fan

    Reply
  9. YouForgot at |

    Carlton Fisk should be WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY higher than 9th!

    Reply
    1. Maryann Johnson at |

      I agree.

      Reply
  10. Greg at |

    Why should he be higher than 9th? With the exception of number 8 (Magglio) every other HR was by a guy on the team who won the series. Just go watch the video again and get drunk and forget that the big red machine whooped Bostons ass in game seven…….nice try Matt Damon

    Reply
  11. Josh at |

    Good list of the top 10 Home Runs in Playoff history. I remembering cheering for Ortiz

    Reply
  12. KASS at |

    MOOKIE WILSON IN 86!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    JOE CARTER WON THE WS WITH A HR.

    Reply
  13. Maryann Johnson at |

    How about that home run that took the lead for the Red sox in game 5 in the 1986 ALCS? He jumped up 4-5 feet in the air unlike the others!

    Reply
  14. Maryann Johnson at |

    You can't judge the Carlton Fisk HR souly on if they won a world series! behind Billy Bukner's error in 1986 and the red sox winning it in 2004,that could be the third most unforgettable moment in red sox history!

    Reply
  15. Maryann Johnson at |

    Not that they should not be #1 and #2 but they both have drawbacks. Maz's homer came with the game tied,unlike Carter's. so any run in the remainder of the ballgame could have been a winner. However,Carter's homer came with the series lead,3-2 so they didn't HAVE to win THAT game. Obviously they are very close.

    Reply
    1. Ben at |

      Maryann, color me impressed with your love and knowledge of baseball. Why weren't you cast in Field of Dreams?

      Reply
      1. Unanimous at |

        i disagree,ben. I know her SHE WAS NOT ALIVE THEN!!!!!!!!!!! by the way happy April Fools day!!!!!!!!

        Reply
  16. Maryann Johnson at |

    Maz wasn't MVP that series. Can you believe it?

    Reply
    1. Bob Canter at |

      No Maryann, he wasn't the MVP, and in fact, NO ONE on the winning Pirates' team was the MVP. This was one of those rare times in history when a player from the LOSING team got that award. I believe it was Bobby Richardson.

      Reply
      1. Unanimous at |

        Richardson DID set many world series records. A player should not be judged by if his team won. I would vote for HIM too. That gets me to thinking, why don't they have "Goat of the year" or"Goat of the World Series" :D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

        Reply
        1. Brian at |

          Because Bill Buckner would have retired the award! :D

          Reply
  17. Ronald Mcdouchebag at |

    Adam KENNEDY's 3 hrs against the Twins is another notable selection in the ALCS.

    Reply
  18. Matt at |

    Bucky Dent?

    Reply
    1. jim at |

      +1

      Bucky F*cking Dent. That was haunts Red Sox fans and always will.

      It was a playoff to get to the playoff, counts in my book.

      Reply
  19. Johnny at |

    Bucky Dent's Home Run was in the Regular Season. It was during a one-game tie-breaker, which is technically considered game 163 of the Regular Season (hence the Yankees 100-63 record in 1978.)

    Reply
  20. Johnny at |

    Its a solid list.

    But I find it curious that Major League Baseball is 140 years old now and 6 of the 10 home runs you've listed happened in the last 16 years. Certainly, there is is more than just one Playoff Home Run pre-1975 that had more significance than Chris Burke's Division Series walk-off, no?

    Reply
  21. Mike at |

    All of you who keep saying Thomson's home run should be #1 don't get that the list is the top playoff homeruns of all time! Thomson's Home Run though in a 3 game tie breaker series was not and is not considered the playoffs. The statistics are contributed to their regular season totals.

    Reply
  22. Mark at |

    Rick Monday in the 1981 NLCS?

    Reply
  23. Robert at |

    Jim Leyritz 96. My favorite moment.

    Reply
  24. Brian at |

    How do you not even consideration to Bobby Thomson's pennant winner over the Brooklyn Dodgers?

    Reply
  25. Peter Boucher at |

    How about Babe Ruth’s called shot in the 1932 World Series against the Chicago Cubs !!!

    Reply
  26. Gabriel at |

    I guess David Freese deserves at least a spot here. His moonshot ended the most exciting World Series game ever and allowed the Redbirds to win the Series.

    Reply
  27. Gabriel at |

    Pujols’ 3 in one game deserve it, too.

    Reply
  28. Peter Boucher at |

    So Bill Mazeroski’s Home Run in 1960 gets the No.1 spot and no mention of Bobby Thompson’s Home Run in 1951 (October 3rd to be exact also the exact day and year that Hall Of Famer Dave Winfield was born). And then too rub salt into the wound, Mazeroski is in The Hall Of Fame and Thompson IS NOT !!! The Veteran’s commitee of The Hall Of Fame SUCKS big time. Just look at the statistics of both of the players and see why. Holy S**t, it finally took them all these years to finally recognize Bert Blyleven with his entry this year. And then they wait just one year after Ron Santo to die before they will induct him in 2012 which I just heard on the news recently. And what’s with Roberto Alomar being inducted ???? He should be in the “Mouthing Off and Spitting On An Umpire” Hall Of Fame which he did one time.

    Reply
  29. Ronnie at |

    How could Fisk’s HR not be in the top 5????

    Reply
  30. Kirk at |

    Scott Spiezio’s home run in game 6 of the 2002 should be considered for this list. It’s started one of the biggest comebacks in World Series history to force a game 7 and help the angels win their first World Series

    Reply

Leave a Reply