37 Responses

  1. Simply Ridiculous
    Simply Ridiculous at |

    Good list!!

    Reply
    1. djc
      djc at |

      What about Alan Matthews (William Russ) from Boy Meets World???

      Reply
  2. SamIAm
    SamIAm at |

    Great list! Especially #'s 1 and 10. Rick Castle is funny and lovable in a unique way (plus quite adorable for us older women), but you can tell how much he loves his daughter. But hands down, Andy Taylor is still the best dad ever. Always just the right amount of punishment and fun-loving…maybe it should be required watching for new parents.

    Reply
  3. Salty Bob
    Salty Bob at |

    "Ward, weren't you a little hard on The Beaver last night?"

    Reply
  4. CB
    CB at |

    i guess the author was going for best PG rated dads. no bill cosby? no archie bunker?

    Reply
  5. CB
    CB at |

    d'oh theres bill cosby!

    Reply
  6. shenlaws
    shenlaws at |

    I would have had a hard time choosing between Heathcliff Huxtable and Andy Taylor, in fact, I probably would have had them in a tie! Archie Bunker wasn't an exceptionally great father, I mean, I loved the character but he was not very positive towards Gloria, now was he?

    In the also-ran category: Tony Danza, Who's the Boss?

    Reply
  7. Lauren
    Lauren at |

    Mmmm, have to go with Cosby. He cracked me up fer several years.

    Reply
  8. Liz
    Liz at |

    Tony Danza is totally an also-ran, as is Michael Seaver from Growning Pains and Whats-His-Name Keaton from Family Ties. Eighties shows – another list for the future?

    Reply
  9. Jonnie Downing
    Jonnie Downing at |

    What a great, concise list of dads! I totally approve of Rick Castle, I think he plays a great dad! Heathcliff Huxtable as #2 is also right on the mark and Andy Taylor as #1 is a great choice! Well done!

    Reply
  10. Liz
    Liz at |

    How cool is it that my mom gives props?

    Reply
  11. TopTenz Master
    TopTenz Master at |

    Andy Griffith was a great TV dad and surrogate father to many a latchkey kid through reruns. Excellent #1 TV Dad!

    Stephen Keaton from Family Ties would have been a nice addition, agreed.

    Reply
  12. Brandi
    Brandi at |

    I know it hasn't been on quite as long… but where is Eric Taylor from Friday Night Lights?!

    Reply
  13. mikw
    mikw at |

    Great list, but what about Dr. Jason Seaver (Alan Thicke) from Growing Pains?? He's the 1st one to pop into my head when I think of the best TV dad.

    I'm surprised you didn't include Tim the Toolman Taylor, & thrilled you didn't include the dad from Blossom , yuck.

    Reply
  14. Jay Po
    Jay Po at |

    Homer Simpson? How about the 2 dads from My Two Dads? They both agreed to raise the girl together without knowing who;s kid it was. That is actually creepy.

    Reply
  15. James
    James at |

    Tony Danza on who's the boss was a moron that made people think anyone of Italian heritage had an IQ of 3. Keaton and Thicke were wimps of the highest order.

    Ward Cleaver was the coolest. He liked guns and hunting, had power tools in his garage and wasn't portrayed as a bumbling twit like so many tv dads are now and Sheriff Taylor is absolutely #1.

    And the

    “Ward, weren’t you a little hard on The Beaver last night?”

    should be added to the dead horse joke hall of fame.

    Reply
  16. albundy
    albundy at |

    Al Bundy! best dad ever

    Reply
  17. loudog
    loudog at |

    Seeley Booth over Jack Arnold from The Wonder Years?!?!

    Reply
  18. Liz
    Liz at |

    While Homer Simpson, Al Bundy, and Jack Arnold were ICONIC dads, I don't think that automatically makes them GOOD dads.

    Reply
  19. loudog
    loudog at |

    Jack Arnold was a good dad. Certainly a cut above the likes of Al Bundy and Homer Simpson.

    Reply
  20. Vivek
    Vivek at |

    Red Forman from 'That '70s Show'. He simply great.

    DUMBASS!!!

    Reply
  21. Jeff
    Jeff at |

    Red Forman from that 70's show!

    Reply
  22. Jess
    Jess at |

    I want 10 9 8 and 6 to be my fathers

    Reply
  23. Gylo
    Gylo at |

    I think Maxwell Sheffield from The Nanny also deserves to be on the list!

    Reply
  24. Toby
    Toby at |

    Ben Cartwright from "Bonanza".

    Charles Ingalls from "Little House on the Prairie".

    Carl Winslow from "Family Matters"

    the dad from "Boy Meets World"

    Reply
  25. notwuti said
    notwuti said at |

    what about john ritter? in 8 simple rules..

    Reply
  26. Marnie
    Marnie at |

    I think Keith Mars from "Veronica Mars" should be on the list, too.

    Reply
  27. kellie
    kellie at |

    DUMBASS!

    im gonna shove my foot up your ass

    so wheres red foremen? clearly anything from that 70s show is the best

    Reply
  28. The Blackbird
    The Blackbird at |

    This list sucks. Why are they all goody-two-shoes dads? My top three would be Al Bundy (Married with Children), Archie Bunker (All in the Family) and Homer Simpson (The Simpsons).

    Reply
    1. Zach Gillette
      Zach Gillette at |

      I agree.

      Reply
  29. paddy
    paddy at |

    jack geller from friends should be here as well… (: he's so funny (:

    Reply
  30. Tamara
    Tamara at |

    HANDS DOWN: MR. DRUMMOND FROM DIFF’RENT STROKES!!!!!

    Reply
  31. Lida
    Lida at |

    Fred McMurray, My three sons: He adopted the youngest son ernie, and continue to let his oldest son, Robbie and daughter-in-law and the triplets live with him. Great dad. Also, Family Affair, Uncle Bill raised his brother’s orphaned twin children Buffy and Jodie. That made him a great dad.

    Reply
  32. Candy
    Candy at |

    What about Little House on the Prairie’s Charles Ingalls? He was the best father by far…. he guided his children with love, strength, and compassion. In fact he was a leader and moral compass for nearly everyone on the show, and not in an overbearing way. He was amazing!

    And Deep Space Nine’s Benjamin Sisko. He was amazing with Jake. Old fashioned values in the new frontier. Love him!

    Reply
  33. TruStory
    TruStory at |

    I think Uncle Phil was a damn good dad too. Lawyer to judge and being the father to Will when his own didnt want’em.

    Reply
  34. LoLo
    LoLo at |

    Dan Conner on Roseanne.

    Reply
  35. K
    K at |

    Your list is missing Howard Cunningham from Happy Days

    Reply

Leave a Reply