10 Reasons Why Wolverine Should Stay Dead



Deaths in comic books are always kind of a tricky thing. When done right, the story can be very effective. When done wrong, it will seriously affect the credibility of the title. Wolverine is the rare character who should remain dead after a great run. Here are the reasons why James Logan Howlett should remain dead. (Yes, in case you didn’t know, Wolverine is going to die. (10/8/2014)


10.  Wolverine’s Death Will Inspire Heroes

Death Of Wolverine

A most serious game of rock, paper, scissors.

In the world of comic books, deaths are almost a necessary part of the motivation for heroes to continue. The trouble is that we are generally not allowed to really meet the people who died. Spider-Man‘s entire story is inspired by the death of Ben Parker. The problem is that we don’t know Ben Parker any more than we know Bruce Wayne’s parents. The impact as well as the heroism only grows when there is a long history with the deceased. Wolverine’s death can become a rallying cry for all of Marvel’s heroes. Can you think of a better end for a superhero that was once referred to as a sociopath.

9. It Could Be The Dawn of a New Comic Age

Wolverine vs Spock

Picture has nothing to with this point, but is just too cool not show. Spock beats Wolverine.

Marvel has shown expertly how the death of one man can change the course of its universe. The problem is that they essentially made the whole thing an alternate universe. However, the Age of Apocalypse storyline showed that one death at one juncture in history can reverberate with worldwide effects. Professor X’s death as a young man created a Butterfly Effect (Not a horrible time travel movie). Heroes could become villains. Villains could become heroes. People intended to be heroes and villains could live normal lives. When Superman died, a platoon stepped in to take his place.

8. The “Captain America Precedent”

Cap on ice.

Cap on ice. Very nice.

The only people who ever truly die in comics have to be sincerely loved by Peter Parker. However, Marvel has established a precedent of a major character dying or being lost signaling a major change in the direction of the company. For instance, you cannot tell the story of Captain America without freezing him in World War 2.  You also cannot tell the story of Captain America without Steve Rogers being a time displaced throwback struggling to learn the modern age.


Yay! Cap’s back!

That is the only possible direction that Wolverine’s story can go in at this point. There should be at least a two decade minimum on Wolverine’s death. After that point, you can give him a John Spartan resurrection in whatever the modern world is in the mid 2030’s or beyond. Logan’s return would then signal a new Comic Age. Also, you could never again tell the story without the story of his death.

7. Wolverine’s Death Raises the Profile of the Deadpool Movie.


Comic book fan boys love Deadpool. Non-comic book fans could not be cattle prodded in every major and minor orifice into knowing the ” merc with a mouth ” at all. This is a problem. This is a bigger problem when you consider the box office for the first Punisher film, the second Punisher film, or the third Punisher film. However, Wolverine’s death will raise Deadpool’s visibility. Deadpool will essentially take the Wolverine role in upcoming story lines. Also, the box office will be significantly improved for a Deadpool Movie with a Wolverine appearance. Wolverine would be nearly an exclusive big screen property. Mutant movies are enhanced at the box office by a Hugh Jackman appearance. The best part is that Jackman sounds like he would be receptive to the idea.  Deadpool comes to theaters in 2016. Of course, none of this benefits the company that actually owns the character of Deadpool.

6. Reign of the Wolverines

x-23 as Wolverine

Are we ready for a new Wolverine…with breasts?

Wolverine’s death will leave a vacuum in the Marvel Universe. This will be similar to the DC Reign of the Supermen and Battle for the Cowl storyline. In the Marvel Universe, Wolverine is an iconic hero. Iconic heroes get replaced. Replacing an iconic hero can lead to epic story lines. There are already a few possible ” replacement Wolverines ” out there. This could be the tipping point that makes Wolverine’s son Daken realize the hero he was meant to be all along.  With a gender switched Thor, then it might be time for Logan’s female clone X-23 to take center stage. Want a real dark horse candidate? How about Wolverine’s own mortal enemy Victor Creed aka Sabertooth?

5. Too Much Was Told About Wolverine

Wow, just creepy. source: http://mrwills.deviantart.com/

Wow, just creepy. source: http://mrwills.deviantart.com/

The best part about Heath Ledger’s portrayal of the Joker was that you never knew where his scars came from.  Jack Nicholson’s Joker was given a backstory that intertwined with Bruce Wayne’s origin. The Heath Ledger version seemed to be much closer to the original vision of the Joker. The Joker works better as a character when the reader knows less about him. The same holds true with Wolverine. Wolverine did not need an origin story or a complete name. The best thing that could happen to Wolverine is less stories written about him. Wolverine works when he is a dark mysterious gun fighter with no memory. He also works well as a legend. Since his popularity never allowed him to be contained, then maybe his death will finally give the character his true focus.

4. The Love Triangle With Cyclops and Jean Grey Never Made Sense

Jean never loved Wolverine

While probably true, not a good idea to make Wolverine mad. Truth hurts, Bub.

On some level, Jean Grey is a hot prep school girl. However, have you moved noticed that nearly every female at the Xavier School for Gifted Youngsters has less than five percent body fat? They also house warrior women as well as other than telepaths. People may argue that Scott Summers is a massive douchebag, but Cyclops is a much better fit for Jean than Logan. If size matters, Wolverine is actually only 5’3″ and Jean Grey is listed at 5’6″ and while relationships involving shorter men and taller females are not unheard of, Jean would never be able to wear heels. The whole thing was forced and painful to watch. The triangle was almost as painful to watch as reading Rogue tell Gambit ” Remy, I love ya but I can’t touch ya. ” As a matter of fact, an adult Rogue was a much better companion for Wolverine than Jean. For the record, the best possible match was ninja telepathic Brit Betsy ” Psylocke ” Braddock.


3. Death Makes Wolverine A Class Myth


The way that a hero dies is every bit as important as the way a hero lives. Beowulf died taking one last swipe at a dragon. With this death, Wolverine is becoming one of Joseph Campbell’s heroes ” with a thousand faces. ” Comic book characters are the modern myths of our times. The best stories are added to the canon and retold, with minor wrinkles, much like the works of Homer. There are obviously religious connotations, but heroic deaths as well as possible resurrections captivate audiences.

2. Wolverine Stories Are Now Free of Continuity

Old Man Logan

Who wouldn’t want Old Man Logan as their Grandfather?

In the Silver Age of Comics, Superman could push the moon back into orbit as well as face a Jimmy Olsen supervillain in the same month.  Post-mortem Wolverine stories will be, by definition, flashbacks or out of the constraints of continuity.  This is not a bad thing. Some of the best Wolverine stories are either out of continuity or flashbacks. This type of storytelling does not hurt Wolverine’s cinematic prospects either. There is significant discussion about the possibility of an Old Man Logan style movie. Wolverine stories are myths. No one even wants continuity to interfere with them. In a world where the term ” shared universe ” reigns supreme, Logan is a singularity in which people don’t even want him in a shared universe.

1. It Makes Financial Sense For Disney


Too bad this guy will never get to meet the Hulk.

The fact of the matter is that it makes zero sense for Disney / Marvel to continue to make comic books promoting a character who is in movies for a rival studio.  It is a bitter pill. Swallow it. Choke on that pill if you have to. Wolverine should not be revived until until Disney can back it up by putting him in a movie. For the record, they should seriously consider wasting the Fantastic Four as well. However, there is an excellent chance Fox might do that on their own. Marvel Comics should head in a direction where it looks exactly like the Marvel Cinematic Universe until all the characters are under Disney Studios umbrella. The only exception is Spider-Man. Spidey remains the face of the comic empire. Wolverine should remain dead.

[ctt tweet=”10 Reasons Why Wolverine Should Stay Dead – http://ctt.ec/IfXQy+” coverup=”IfXQy”]
Love superhero lists as much as we do?.
Leap over to our list of the 10 Greatest Spider-man Comics. Or, if you favor the villains, see who we ranked as the Top 10 Comic Villains.
Other Articles you Might Like
Liked it? Take a second to support Toptenz.net on Patreon!


  1. Wolverine doesn’t not work now the mystery is resolved. We’ve known who the Joker is ever since Killing Joke and it didn’t make his charcter worthless because he was still the chaotic force of evil people loved him for. People didn’t mainly love Logan for the mystery they loved him for being a bad ass with a inner conflict between being a man of honour and a beserker animal

  2. Just because you think he should die, doesn’t mean Marvel will kill him off permanently. Yes Logan has been boring for quite some time. However take another equally boring character Superman as far as I’m concerned he’s never been interesting. Yet as long as he makes DC money they won’t kill him off and like Superman Wolverine has a huge fanbase, so both characters will continue to make a profit. Before I get hate I really don’t like Wolverine, just pointing out that comic books are more about sales then actual character development. Do I care if they kill him? Not really. Am I dumb enough to think Marvel/Disney would actually kill him off? Nope. Marvel’s creative ability is long gone. Take what they did to Thor and Captain America for example.

  3. You know what grinds my gears…marvel killing the one CANADIAN super hero that was in the mainstream. Kill off someone else, let us have our Wolverine!

  4. Furthermore, everyone wants wolverine in the MCU shared universe. Even Hugh Jackman wants wolverine in the MCU shared universe. How else will we ever get the hulk vs wolverine every wolverine fan has been waiting for.

  5. This article is ridiculous and makes little to no sense. You cannot replace wolverine, killing him does not affect Fox in any way whatsoever, and the “love triangle” had more to do with is first love Rose rather then anything to actually do with Jean, plus being short hasn’t really hurt his luck with women. I have to wonder if the person writing this article knows anything about the actual character, industry, or if they have just read a few headlines and watched the movies. Very sad really. ,

  6. That is completely stupid. The Ultimate marvel branch, sink totally after the ultimate wolverine dead. Don´t they never learn, that some heroes are irreplaceable!!!!!!!!!!!

  7. the biggest problem Disney Marvel studios currently face is the fact that Wolverine, Deadpool, and Spider-man belong to other studios. Without those 3 in Marvel Studios, the studio will ever only be a fraction of its total potential. Killing Wolverine is just going to make the character more popular.

  8. Some of the points you made were silly but I could get behind them until you got to #1…..way off track with that one

  9. #1 makes no sense because since day one of Disney owning marvel they have not interfered with marvel comics, marvel studios has zero decision making power in marvel comics affairs…

    • And besides that, movies promote the comics, comics don’t promote the movies. People who don’t read comics will still go to the movies, and they are more likely to pick up the comics if they enjoy the movies. There is almost always a spike in comic sales after a successful movie. It is in Disney and Marvel’s best interest to continue to publish these books to make money off of the movies they aren’t producing

  10. I was with you until the #1 point. Marvel will not subdue the XMen to belittle Fox. It makes no sense. People nowadays don’t go from comics to movies, they go from movies to comics. Fox’s movies benefit Marvel, not the other way around. In the 80’s, you would’ve been correct. Not now.