Top 10 Comic Book Villains Who Should Have Gone Legit


Right after raptors with laser guns, villains are the thing that brings all stories to life. Who would Batman be without the Joker if not just a nerdy meathead in a silly Halloween costume? And if it wasn’t for liberals, Fox News would not be the bastion of unintentional comedy it is today. Everyone needs a villain. But sometimes writers are so eager to create a nemesis for their protagonists that they forget the most important thing: the villains’ motives. Be it revenge, insanity or simply their desire to bang the hero (I am looking at you Agent Smith), it is the motivation of the villain that ultimately sells the character. The following 10 examples failed at that miserably:

10. Dr. Blight (Captain Planet)

dr blight

All in all, none of the baddies from Captain Planet are good villains. We’re talking about the kind of people who if handed a tanker full of gasoline, would use it to burn down a penguin nursery, instead of exchanging it for a semi-truck filled with gold, considering today’s prices. Even then, Dr. Blight is the worst example out of the bunch.

Why? Because we’re potentially talking about the smartest person on the planet, who once invented a rocket which can travel to Venus in a matter of hours AND a freaking time machine (for reals). And yet, somehow she cannot figure out that with one little upgrade that would stop her latest invention from strangling baby ducks with robot tentacles, she could become the richest human on Earth in a matter of days. Her baffling career choice pisses me off the most because out of all the Captain Planet villains she’s the one with actual potential, like a nun with DD knockers.

9. Captain Cold (The Flash)

captain cold

Captain Cold, arguably The Flash’s greatest enemy, is your typical ice-themed villain scientist. Think Mr. Freeze, with one notable difference: Captain Cold is not insane. So why exactly is he a villain? Nobody snows (zing! I’ll let myself out…)

See, the thing we have to make clear is that, when you get down to it, there really is no point to supper villainy if you have other options. When you’re a super villain you have to constantly live in fear, knowing that the heroes can at any time storm your iceberg shaped fortress, takes away your loot and throws you in rapetastic jail. But there is squat they can do if you make your living the legal way.

Captain Cold has other options. He’s a technological genius whose gun can create insanely low temperatures. That simply has to have some super important applications in real life. True, the only one I can think of is flash freezing booze to make ice cream, but I am not the totally sane genius like Cold is.

8. Radioactive Man (The Avengers)

radioactive man

Not to be confused with the Simpsons’ character, Marvel’s Radioactive Man is one Chen Lu, a Chinese nuclear physicist who gains powers of manipulating radiation through the magic of science. His first task was to kill Thor, after which he became the recurring villain for the Avengers, though the comics did skip out on one, tiny little thing: Why? Why in tap-dancing Jesus’ name is Chen a villain?

You might try to make the case that he seeks revenge on the Avengers because… Thor defeated him after Chen tried to brutally murder him? No. This guy was a nuclear scientist. He obviously is quite smart, so it should take this guy about 2 to 3 seconds to figure out all the cool, legal ways he could make a living with his powers of radioactivity, including but not limited to, oh I don’t know, virtually free energy or repairing nuclear reactors? You know, start small, and move up. I heard Japan could really use some help right about now.

7. Toyman (Superman)


Toyman is the on-and-off Superman villain and a mechanical genius who turns seemingly innocent toys into weapons of destruction and chaos… because he could not find a job as a toymaker. Let’s back up a bit…

We will have to go all the way back to the character’s original version, because his current incarnation is admittedly insane and thus not suitable for leveled, logical analysis (which is exactly what I am doing here, shut up). In the beginning, Toyman was just a Limey toymaker who apparently got put out of business by Lex Luthor. After this minor setback he only did the most illogical thing possible: he turned to crime, using high-tech machines he probably built out of dismantled bicycles. That’s like inventing a new type of nuclear-powered laser to blow up the Apple Store that fired you: as in, completely missing the point. While I am at it.

6. Mysterio (Spider-man)


You might know Mysterio as the fish bowl Spider-man villain and only man in existence to make Lady Gaga go “Want to maybe tone it down a bit, buddy?” He is (or maybe was? It’s impossible to keep up with modern comics without a complex chart and a new type of math algorithm) a master illusionist and hypnotist, a career he consciously went into because he felt his job in Hollywood was going nowhere.

In his pre-idiot days Mysterio was a special effects wizard who wanted to make it big in the moving pictures. Then, one day, he decided this whole “pursuing your dreams” thing was a dead-end and he became a super villain whose abilities could revolutionize entertainment as we know it. To give you the idea of the scope of Mysterio’s powers: he once hypnotized Spider-man to think he was 6 inches tall. If this guy only applied half of his expertise to his original job, he could reinvent the very idea of a movie (and especially porn) and make exactly a 100 billion dollars. But then he wouldn’t have the excuse to dress up as an anthropomorphic sperm-head, so at least we know it must have been a tough decision.

5. Mirror Master (The Flash)

mirror master

Mirror Master first appeared in Flash #105 over 50 years ago as a small time crook who only had one dream: To go inside a mirror reflection. There is a double twist to his origin story when MM actually succeeds in stepping into a mirror with the help of Science! (exclamation mark mandatory) and it’s revealed that he actually wasn’t mentally retarded this whole time. But then he had to go and be a criminal.

When a person completely revolutionizes our understanding of the laws of physics, the proper thing to do is to apply for your Nobel Prize and start issuing numbers to those infamous Nobel sluts you keep hearing about. That’s just for publishing the theory on how the frick does one go inside a mirror, but that’s not all. Mirror Master’s devices also let him travel at basically the speed of light, enter other dimensions and explore other plains of existence (like… the afterlife?) The possibilities for legal profits in this case are what scientists refer to as “humongahugealicious” so the only logical conclusion is that Mirror Master is suffering from a rare condition where he can only achieve sexual satisfaction while stealing old ladies’ jewelry and making horrible life decisions.

4. Electro (Spiderman)


Originally the Spider-man villain Electro was just Max Dillon, an aspiring electrical engineer convinced by his mother to settle for a lesser job of an electrical lineman. Dillon’s story had all the necessary elements of a good villain origin: feelings of inadequacy brought on by his mom, yearning to be respected and magical lightning, which ultimately transformed Max into Electro.

As a giant, walking capacitor Max of course could have made a living for himself the legal way, but he had something to prove. He wanted everyone to know that he is not a failure, that he is powerful, that he is to be feared etc. Awesome. The problem? Electro, like all comic book villains, loses to the main hero, constantly. He may get in an electric punch every now and again, but in the end Electro can’t “win” over Spidey, for reasons obvious. And he doesn’t even hatch up most of his evil plans, more often serving as an accomplice (or lapdog if you will) to other, smarter villains. Ultimately Electro would have better luck gaining the respect of the world if he just stayed home and managed to not choke to death on a dinner roll.

3. Livewire (Superman)


The origin of Leslie “Livewire” Willis is a Rube Goldberg machination of lazy writing and face palms, but in the end it all came down to magic lightning which turned Leslie into basically pure energy. With one small accident she has evolved beyond the imperfect human body into, quite possibly, a new state of being. Unfortunately, it was a state of bad life choices and slutty clothes. In conclusion, all higher beings are idiots.

The main reason why it’s hard to take Livewire’s villain motivation seriously is because before the accident she was a female Howard Stern, a shock jockey making a living out of saying weird stuff into a microphone every night. I’d buy it if after transcending humanity her first order of business was to take over the radio ways and Rick Roll the planet or transmit porn audio books through the Vatican’s airways. Super villainy though? Pretty low on the list.

2. Reverse Flash (The Flash)


Wow, I am really ragging on Flash’s villains, aren’t I? OK, you got me. A Flash villain touched my bathing suit area when I was 19. Yes, it was technically a costumed prostitute whom I paid to do exactly that, but still, I wanted you to know that.

Anyway, Reverse Flash. There actually were about 3 characters that donned the mantle of Reverse Flash and outside the original one, all of them were insane, so they’re off the table. Ed Clariss however does not get off that easy. Clariss was a scientist who believed he was the one who had invented the formula that gave the original Flash his powers but no one believed him. So, naturally, he turned to crime despite already being a renowned scientist in Europe. This is not really a case of a supervillain going legit, but rather a stable minded scientist driven to crime due to lazy writing. Yes, turning yourself into a speedster villain will surely convince the people that you’re a scientific genius. That’s why when people doubt my Ph.D. in Smartmaking I prove them wrong by setting their deceased loved ones on fire.

1.  Lex Luthor

lex luthor

He’s a Superman villain. You might have heard of him.

In the DC Universe Lex Luthor is considered one of the smartest, if not the smartest, humans on Earth, but the problem with genius character is that in most cases a non-genius is writing them. This can be quite troublesome because regular people make simple mistakes and miss stuff which geniuses would not. This brings us to Luthor’s villainy.

Luthor is smart, rich and ambitious, and yet every now and again he jumps into a huge exoskeleton powered by Kryptonite and Penis Envy and battles Superman in space. Luthor’s deal is that he feels a bit threatened by the demigod in blue tights and wants to destroy him. It does make him petty but it doesn’t ruin the character. What does do that is how Luthor decided to go about it. Usually Lex is a complex, well-written character, but as a villain he’s on the same level as Snidely Whiplash: He’s obvious, he’s stupid, he’s rash, he’s emotional etc. If Lex was serious about killing Superman he would be all smiles and puppy hugs on the outside, pretending to be Sups’ ally and friend for years, and when he least expected it BAM, Kryptonite enema. But until he figures that out, Luthor has no business being evil because it undermines his very character.

by Rick Raule

Other Articles you Might Like
Liked it? Take a second to support on Patreon!


  1. Robert Igles on

    “Unfortunately, it was a state of bad life choices and slutty clothes.”
    Looks like she’s using a swimsuit. I’d call this neckbeard writers mom a slut if I’d ever saw her on the beach.

  2. “she’s the one with actual potential, like a nun with DD knockers.”

    Stopped reading after this juvenile nonsense.

  3. Stephen Sharper on

    Someone needs a lil East Asian history education. The first thing you may learn is that Chinese absolutely positively hate the Japanese and have since 1894 lol. So radioactive wanting to get his ass kicked by a God rather than help the Japanese is not insanity at all but in reality entirely rational. Secondly being a resident in China has taught me many things, namely that these fools have virtually no incentive for making money what so ever regardless of education level. Might want to take this guy off the list

  4. In the well-written stories featuring Luthor, he is certainly not obvious, stupid, rash, or emotional. In comics that have been running a long time with many different writers, a character should be judged by the high points, not the average.

  5. While I can’t comment on the comics, at least in the animated series I’d have to say Harley Quinn was a perfect candidate for a bad girl turned good. She actually helped Batman from time to time and seemed to have a good heart in everything she did even though she was loyal to the Joker. She’d have my vote at #1.

    • Impossible because Harley was a regular doctor who turned insane. As our writer stated being insane automatically ruled you out of this list because comic insanity rarely goes away, and if it does it always seems to come back. (Eyes Harvey Dent)

  6. Electro has tried to go legit quite a few times. His main problem is that his powers are unstable.

    He tried selling himself to a power company, but he couldn’t maintain a constant level of energy and they got rid of him. He’s paired up with multiple villians before in order to improve his powers or to find a way to stabalize himself.

  7. “In the beginning, Toyman was just a Limey toymaker who apparently got put out of business by Lex Luthor”
    That’s not really the beginning. He began much further back, in 1943. He was an american who had nothing to do with Lex Luther (who was an evil scientist in those days, not a businessman / politician). He made toys for crime, but nothing you’d call “high tech”, even for those times. They were unrealistic and unworkable, but hey it’s comics. I love the old toyman and shudder to think what they have done with him in modern comics, which I avoid like the plague.

  8. I myself have always wondered why Bullseye wouldn’t have just went on to be the best quarterback in the NFL.

    • Bullseye is crazy and loves to kill, that’s his driving motivation. He doesn’t care about fame or money as much as he likes to hurt things.

  9. I think its easy enough to say that Luthor is openly hostile to Superman because of his own ego.

  10. It’s a great list, but I think you miss the point about Luthor. Luther is a massive self-centered douche bag. He is completely in love with his own sense of self importance and everyone around him are tools to be manipulated or tossed aside. If you go back to the John Byrne Superman reboot he ran Metropolis like his own private fiefdom and butted heads with Superman because the big guy would not submit to his will.

    The other thing is, Luthor despises Superman because he is an alien. To him Superman is an enemy because Mankind should be looking up to Lex Luthor, Super Man, rather than Superman. Luthor’s massive ego is in many ways a greater enemy than the last son of Krypton himself.

    • Ess Tii Eph Yu on

      No, I think the person who made this post himself misses the point in that if he can form complete sentences with “strong” and “powerful” words, why does he resort to sounding like a complete lobotomized imbecile in sometimes describing these villains? I get it, he doesn’t understand why they choose to be villains, or how they’d make themselves for a much better use, however, his comparisons are utter rubbish. I could come up with a better article than this. :/

      • “I could come up with a better article than this.”

        I have read comments similar to this hundreds of times. And so far, I have had only 2 people put their money where there mouth is and actually contribute and article. Will you be the third or is this simply more hot air? Send submissions to [email protected].