26 Responses

  1. rachid at |

    where is nadia comaneci???? she is the gratest gymnast in history!

    Reply
    1. Stéphane at |

      Indeed, without Nadia, this list is null and void.

      Reply
  2. Trixie at |

    Rachid beat me to it.. I recognize a top ten list can't include everyone, but seeing as how 4 gymnasts made this list, I don't see how Nadia could not have been one of them.

    Reply
  3. Pax at |

    This is a good list but… it's hard to accept this list as a 'greatest' list when athletes like Jackie Joyner-Kersee, Bonnie Blair, Nadia Comaneci, Tracy Caulkins, Florence Griffith Joyner, etc aren't included. Nadia, for example, is considered by many as the greatest gymnast of all-time yet she barely makes the list at 9 (thanks TopTenz Master) and even gets beaten by 4 other gymnast based on the parameters used. I also expected to see Olga Korbut in here somewhere…

    This list is more like comparing simple career numbers vs peak performance.

    Reply
  4. mmuunnttee at |

    nice list but i'm preety sure that number one is Nadia Comaneci but nice job

    Reply
    1. manciurian at |

      Nadia isn't exactly number one but it should bee in the list

      Reply
  5. Shayin Beijing at |

    Very US-centric choices of swimmers. No argument with Jenny Thomson, but the others were decent swimmers with their numbers inflated by virtue of being in US relay teams. Dawn Fraser or Krisztina Egerszegi were far greater swimmers, without the artificial relay numbers to push them along.

    Reply
  6. David at |

    Some great posts and many thanks for all your comments! Whether you agree with the Luchies Olympic Formula (LOF), let’s not forget that my selection of this list was based on that key factor. Using this formula, Nadia Comaneci received five five golds, three silvers and one bronze for a total of 36 points, and therefore, I stand to be corrected as she did in fact place as number nine on this list nudging out Amy Van Dyken. As for comparing simple career numbers versus peak performance, let’s not forget Birgit Schmidt-Fischer, Dara Torres, and Raisa Smetanina all made the list using the same formula. Finally, the potentially inflated numbers for swimmers for team medals could also be true of gymnast, but again remember, efforts at objectivity was made by equally applying the LOF. Thanks again for bringing Nadia Comaneci to my attention. My oversight was certainly not intentional.

    Reply
  7. lb at |

    the greatest olympian ever is just that, shes not a summer olympian and shes not a winter olympian, shes both, Canadian Clara Hughes , the multi medalist in both the summer and winter olympics (cycling/speed skating) , no other olympian has accomplished that feat.

    Reply
    1. dg at |

      absolutely! She’s now 40 years old and still our most talented athlete! Go Clara!

      Reply
  8. Rich at |

    without Nadia, this list is dead on arrival

    Reply
  9. rachid at |

    I'm so proud that people want Nadia on this list, because I'm half Romanian

    Reply
    1. vasiauvi at |

      @rachid

      I'm so proud to be a "full" Romanian! ;)

      Reply
  10. tasmanian devil at |

    Typical American list. They seem to think the level of athletic brilliance is directly related to the number of medals they have won. Quantity over quality. What about those athletes who compete in events where there is only one gold to win (e.g. Judo). These people train their whole life for one chance at gold. If the number of medals determines ones greatness then obviously athletes like gymnasts and swimmers are going to top the list. A swimmer can win 7 gold medals by swimming a little bit further or changing their technique slightly. If greatness was determined by dignity, honour and humility there wouldn't be many Americans on the list.

    Reply
  11. spk at |

    Granted, as a Canadian, I'm a little biased here…but I'd think you would have to include Clara Hughes. I'm not aware of too many Olympians who have participated in both the Summer and Winter Olympics…much less won medals in both. Over her career in speed skating and cycling she has won a gold medal (speed skating), one silver (speed skating), and 4 bronze medals, (cycling and speed skating).

    Reply
  12. Lex at |

    Where's Kerri Strug?!?

    Reply
  13. London La Quinta at |

    MICHELLE KWAN. Greatest.

    Reply
  14. qystein at |

    Marit Bjorgen???

    Reply
  15. i-tasik at |

    made them as an inspiration, so we are able to succeed like them.

    Reply
  16. ion at |

    Nadia is no. 1.

    Reply
  17. Peter Boucher at |

    Katarina Witt (figure skating), Fanny Blankers Koen (track and field), Babe Didrickson (track and field), Jackie Joyner Kersee (track and field), Olga Korbut (gymnastics), Dawn Fraser (swimming), Fu Ming-Xia (diving), Bonnie Blair, (Speed Skating), Mary Lou Retton (gymnastics), Sonia Henje (figure skating), Canadian Women’s Ice Hockey Team, Patricia McCormack (diving), Wilma Rudolph (track and field), Wyomia Tyus (track and field), 1976 East Germany women’s swim team starring Kornelia Ender, Ludmilla Tereshkova (gymnastics), the late Florence Griffith Joyner (track and field), Jenny Thompson (swimming)

    Reply
    1. Peter Boucher at |

      Shall I dig deeper into the list that I have accumulated ????

      Reply
  18. Grambo at |

    Yegorova was found gilty in taking performance enhanced drugs in 2002. Just sayin’..

    Reply

Leave a Reply