56 Responses

  1. Keith Watabayashi at |

    Should have been way more specific and said "top ten COMIC BOOK anti-heroes", even though Conan wouldn't count. Great idea for a list but short-sighted in my opinion. Even excluding literature, plays, film, and general mythology/folklore (Pied Piper of Hamlin, Anansi, Hercules, etc.) there are some pretty blaring characters missing. Batman, first and foremost, V from V for Vendetta, Morpheus from Sandman, Jonah Hex, pretty much the entire cast from Preacher, and so on and so on.

    Reply
    1. katefan at |

      Darn it, I thought I had called it "Top Ten Comic Book Anti-Heroes"…

      I had considered Batman for the list but he has a strict code versus killing, as well as being a founding member of the Justice League as well as the patron of the Bat family. The reasons I considered Wolverine belonging at number eight factored into me keeping Batman out of the top ten.

      Your other suggestions are good ones, but I weighed popularity with notoriety and longevity. And in some cases-like Sandman, for example-there has been more than one. Otherwise Grendel may have made the list.

      Reply
  2. themufc1999 at |

    Where is Judge Dredd. He'd kick any of the above's asses. Well maybe Rorshach would give him a run for his money.

    Reply
    1. katefan at |

      Sadly, he would have made number ten, if not for that horrible Stallone movie…

      Reply
  3. Night-Watcher at |

    Elektra is missing , beside ironman doesnt count in my opinion but still good list , thanks for posting

    Reply
  4. Tom at |

    Oh my Gawd you people are geeks! Well, I guess I am too because I kinda thought this list was cool. :)

    Reply
  5. Brendan at |

    How about spawn?

    Reply
    1. MITCH at |

      seriously spawn is #1 but maybe not well known enough for it but needs to be in the top 10

      Reply
  6. Des at |

    No Lobo. Seriously?

    Reply
    1. CapN at |

      I second, and third this one.

      Reply
      1. 187TripleOG at |

        This list is seriously a joke without Lobo…i refuse to even acknowledge this list…dethrone Conan and put the real frag’n bastnitch on number 1. Seriously who wrote this?

        Reply
  7. katefan at |

    In regards to Elektra, I appreciate her part in the MU and as part of Daredevil's mythos, but overall she does not have quite the impact that someone like Catwoman has over the years.

    Spawn. Good choice, and if I had made a top twenty list he probably would be on it.

    Lobo? I like the main man in small amounts and he had his own series and he is as two-dimensional as Deadpool, but DP has had better success.

    Reply
    1. 187TripleOG at |

      Two dimensional? Lobo raised space dophins…have you ever raised a dophin? Lobo whipped everyone in DC..got bored crossed over to marveland kicked Logan in the face..then beat up Santa Claus for good measure.

      Deadpool was forever damned and lost because of his love affair with Death…the actual angel of Death. Just because your not a fan or haven’t read the comics does not mean they are two dimensional.

      Reply
  8. Comic Book Covers at |

    I think Iron Man may be the lest anti-hero on this list. I guess his recent actions have him closer than before but I wouldn't consider him an anti-hero. I think Venom is more likely to be on this list. But he switches evil to good to neutral and so forth, so who knows what he is now? Chaotic-Neutral?

    Reply
  9. Houstonwino at |

    No Jonah Hex??? ;)

    I am not much of a comic geek, but I sure love that one when I was a kid.

    Reply
  10. katefan at |

    I went with more than just recent actions. My examples above happened some years ago, when War Machine first appeared back in '92. Then there is the Armor Wars issue and Gremlin's death, which happened before that.

    There was also an Iron Man annual where he teamed up with Captain America and he used a piece of technology to wipe his secret identity from the minds of everyone on the planet who knew it. That happened during the Heroes Return era, so that was maybe ten years ago now?

    So Stark's actions are nothing new, just a little more extreme.

    Venom? He had a big run in the nineties but he simply did not have the legs, there was no longevity to him. Brock is now, what, Anti-Venom? And The Scorpion is now the new Venom? Brock is an also-ran.

    Jonah Hex is an excellent choice. I especially liked the horror western stuff DC published during the nineties. I have been a fan of Tim Truman's art going back to his Grimjack days.

    And darn it, if Grimjack was still being published and written by John Ostrander I would have put him on the list.

    Reply
  11. Jordor at |

    A great anti-hero, though understandably not on the list, is Penance that arose frome the Marvel Civil War comics. He had his own 5 part storyline thereafter and became a member of the Thunderbolts. Great character with a really dark back story. Look him up!

    Reply
  12. Schahryar Fekri at |

    Punisher!!?

    Reply
  13. dbjkrbgjkbsjk at |

    Where the hell is Ghost Rider? And the hell is Iron Man an anti hero?

    Reply
  14. dbjkrbgjkbsjk at |

    Punisher should be #1

    Reply
  15. lunch at |

    really how can spawn not be on this list? prince namor is a punk marvel version of aquaman. spawn is the ultimate antihero

    Reply
  16. Weez at |

    in all actuality, this list should be entitled ‘Top Ten Anti-Heroes from marvel and dc’.
    i forgive you, but when are people going to realize that marvel and dc are not the end of the comicbook stand?
    try johnny c. from ‘johnny the homicidal maniac’ by slave labor
    the mask from ‘the mask’ & ‘return of the mask’ by dark horse
    or something from darkhorse that’s a little more mainstream, marv from ‘sin city’

    while i disagree with your pick of iron man, i did enjoy the list. however, i would like to recommend you branch out a little. unless of course you have read the above comics and just didn’t care for them; in which case, we have very different tastes.

    Reply
  17. tjs at |

    Wolverine should be at no. 2 or somethin.. deadpool should be up here too..!!

    Reply
  18. Harley_Quinn27 at |

    think you should do a top 10 or worst 10 batman villans one or female comic book charecters one :)

    Reply
  19. Murphy at |

    Ya fergot to mention the deadliest man in the west, Jonah Hex. Forget the movie ever happened.

    Reply
  20. reed at |

    actually, hulks first appearance was in hulk #1 ’62. not tales to astonish

    Reply
  21. Colleen Walllace at |

    deadpool or cat woman should have been number one.

    Reply
  22. Dude at |

    No Spawn? Wolverine should be at least at N°2

    Reply
  23. Dude at |

    Ahhhhhhhhhh and you forget LOBO!

    Reply
  24. Nate at |

    This list is missing the best anti-hero of all…. Spawn… seriously who is better ???

    Reply
  25. penile papules at |

    Damn too many badasses, Hulk definitely takes the cake. Indestructible! The more you push, the harder he pushes back and thats exactly what my mentality is all about!

    Reply
  26. MatthewZD at |

    Iron Man an anti-hero?? I agree with someone earlier that said he’s the least anti-hero-like on this list.

    I also disagree with including Conan. Yes, he gained popularity thanks to the comic published by Marvel, but he was not an original Marvel creation. He started in pulp magazines in the early 1930s. By the same token, you could count Han Solo since Marvel published the Star Wars comic in the 70s and 80s.

    Drop Iron Man and Conan and add Elektra and someone from Preacher (either Jesse, Cassidy, or the Saint of Killers).

    I was a bit surprised that Deadpool is included on the list, but not Deathstroke the Terminator. I’m assuming the writer dismissed the original because he’s seen as more villain than hero.

    Reply
  27. Jessica26 at |

    Green Arrow should have at least been # 10……..

    GREEN ARROW…………..

    Reply
  28. The Man Who Should Not Be King at |

    Nice work. Possibly the only comic-character-list-thing I have ever liked. Dunno about conan as number 1. You get all these total bad-asses that everyone are familiar with, as you get down the list you’re guessing who will be number 1, and it’s…conan?

    And now for some helpful hints.

    Drop Conan, Add lobo (not in first place though).

    Put John Constantine in front of Iron Man (he’s a way bigger bastard. He’s also way cooler).

    Deadpool, as a rule, must not come last.

    I’m really uneasy about cat-woman.

    where’s green arrow (the broke, street-wise green arrow that is. Connor Hawke annoyed the @#$%! out of me).

    Where is judge dredd, man? you can’t have cat-woman while not having ol’ dredd.

    But don’t let all that make you take the comment the wrong way. This is a REALLY good list, and best all, Thor isn’t at number 1!

    -The Man Who Must Not Be King (He tolerates you)

    Reply
  29. lord-enten at |

    No Venom???? Come on, man! Venom is a way cooler anti-hero than Catwoman or Sub-Mariner, for sure! I mean, he’s the “Lethal Protector”! Still, a pretty good list besides that.

    Reply
  30. lobo at |

    You guys forgot one, a guy that gave Superman a lot of hell, do you all remember LOBO, the main man. Bet you did not even think of him, he was even classified to be an immortal or untouchable by heaven itself, to him hell was a vacation and heaven was a place where he can just cause havoc for the fun of it. Who in their sane minds would take on lobo. Except maybe supergirl who had him wrapped around her little finger and maybe the hulk and perhaps wolverine aswell. So Here’s to lobo.

    Reply
  31. mighty black adam at |

    no black adam really? he should be top 5…

    Reply
  32. devis at |

    How is Conan number one in this list. He lacks the depth of many of the other characters on this list.

    Reply
  33. JJ at |

    Idk man, not a bad list but I HIGHLY disagree with Ironman and Conan too, I don’t think Ironman is an anti-hero, Conan is one, I just don’t like him, I would do it more like this

    10. Deadpool

    9. The Hulk

    8. Ghost Rider

    7. Venom

    6. Moon Knight

    5. Rorschach

    4. Deathstroke

    3. The Punisher

    2. Lobo

    1. Wolverine

    And John Constantine, Elektra, The Comedian, Magneto, Bane, Black Adam, Namor, Catwoman, Black Widow and Gambit would make top 20, Spawn and Dredd too, but you said only Marvel and DC so they don’t count. Oh yeah, you said something about Batman? He’s just about as far away from an anti-hero as they get.

    Reply
  34. JJ at |

    I would also have included Poison Ivy, I know she’s mostly a villain, but she really wants to save the Eco system (which is a good thing) but she does it in a flawed way, the perfect definition of an anti-hero, and wasn’t she part of a superhero team with Catwoman and Zatanna at some point, I’m pretty sure she was.

    Reply
  35. Rachel at |

    You gotta include Red X from teen titans

    Reply
  36. Joseph at |

    Where is Judge Dredd?!?!

    Reply
  37. javier at |

    gambit?. Ghost rider?

    Reply
  38. Will at |

    You forgot to add Wonder Woman to this list. She is an anti-hero now.

    Reply
  39. Warrior at |

    And where’s Lobo? thats greatest bastard of all time!

    Reply
    1. John at |

      Totally agree – Lobo defines anti-hero!

      Reply
  40. Lori at |

    Lady Death!

    Reply
  41. MaxP at |

    Dark Horse’s X should be on the list and should be as popular as Bat Man. He is awesome. The fact he isn’t famous and on the list is criminal! He’s one bad-@$$ anti-hero to be sure!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Current day month ye@r *